A quality of earnings report is an independent review of your company’s profit that tests whether the earnings a buyer is paying for are real, recurring and backed by cash. Its main output is a normalized EBITDA figure the buyer can rely on, along with the working capital and debt items that change what you take home. Buyers order one after an offer is signed. Sellers can order their own first, and often should.
It is the step where many deals go quiet. In Axial’s study of signed letters of intent that fell apart in 2025, 21.3% broke on quality of earnings reviews that did not support the seller’s figures. That figure counts only the deals that died, not the ones that closed at a lower price. This guide explains what the report covers, how it differs from your annual statements, what it costs, and how to be ready for it.
What is a quality of earnings report?
Your financial statements say what the business earned. A quality of earnings report, often shortened to QoE, asks whether that profit will still be there after you leave. It looks at where the earnings come from, how steady they are, and whether the cash in the bank matches the profit on paper.
The report is built for a transaction, not for the CRA or the bank. A buyer pays a multiple of your earnings, so it needs to know the earnings are sound before it wires the money. Think of it as the accountant’s version of a building inspection: the price is agreed in principle, and now someone checks the foundation.
At its centre is the number we covered in what is normalized EBITDA: your profit restated to a typical year under a new owner. The QoE team rebuilds that number from the records, line by line, and decides which of your adjustments it accepts.
What is included in a quality of earnings report?
No two reports are identical, and the scope is agreed with whoever orders it. Most cover the same ground.
- Normalized EBITDA for the last two or three years and the year to date, with each adjustment listed, explained and either accepted or rejected.
- Revenue quality: how much comes from your largest customers, how much repeats each year, and whether growth came from price, volume or one big order.
- Proof of cash: deposits in the bank traced back to the sales on the books.
- Gross margin and cost trends, and the reasons behind any sharp change.
- Payroll: who is on it, what they are paid, and who would need to be hired if you or a family member left.
- Net working capital: the receivables, inventory and payables the business needs to run, which usually becomes the target, or peg, in the purchase agreement.
- Debt and debt-like items: loans, leases, unpaid bonuses, deferred revenue and taxes owing, which come off the price.
- Accounting policies: when revenue is recorded, how inventory is valued, and whether any of it flatters the latest year.
The last three items matter more than owners expect. As we explain in how much is my business worth, the multiple applies to EBITDA, but working capital and debt decide how much of that price reaches you.
Quality of earnings report vs audit
Owners often assume their statements already answer the buyer’s questions. Usually they don’t, because each kind of report answers a different question.
- A compilation, the most common report for owner-managed Canadian companies, presents your numbers in proper form. Under the standard called CSRS 4200, which replaced the old Notice to Reader, the accountant does not test them. It is not an audit or a review.
- A review engagement adds inquiry and analysis, and gives limited comfort that the statements are reasonable.
- An audit tests whether the statements are fairly presented under the accounting rules. It looks back, at whether last year was recorded correctly.
- A quality of earnings report looks forward. It asks whether the profit is repeatable, what a new owner would actually earn, and what a buyer should pay for it. It gives no audit opinion and is written for one deal.
An audited company still gets a QoE when it sells. A company with only compiled statements gets a harder one, because there is less underneath for the buyer’s accountants to rely on.
Sell-side vs buy-side quality of earnings
A buy-side report is ordered and paid for by the buyer, and written for the buyer. It usually starts after the letter of intent is signed, when you have agreed to stop talking to other buyers for a period. Its findings arrive in the middle of that exclusivity.
A sell-side report is one you order before you go to market. The same kind of firm does the same kind of work, but you see the findings first, while you still have time to fix a problem, drop a weak add-back, or document it properly. The buyer will still do its own work. It now starts from a tested number instead of a claim.
The same findings, found at two different times
What a buyer’s quality of earnings usually finds
The findings are rarely dramatic. They are small, ordinary things that each move the number a little, and the multiple turns each one into real money.
- “One-time” costs that turn up every year under a new name.
- Personal spending through the company that cannot be proven either way.
- A strong final year built on deferred repairs, a delayed hire or one large order.
- Rent on a building you own, charged below market.
- Customer concentration that wasn’t obvious until the revenue was split by name.
- Working capital below what the business normally needs, which becomes a price reduction at closing.
None of this is unusual. The trouble is when you hear it. The first offer was based on your number. The buyer’s number arrives weeks later, after the other buyers have moved on, and you negotiate it with far less leverage than you had at the start. We describe how that leverage slips away in what to do with an unsolicited offer, and most private equity buyers run this step as a matter of course.
The buyer’s report arrives after your leverage has gone. Yours arrives while you still have it.
Who prepares a quality of earnings report?
An independent accounting firm, usually its transaction advisory or deal team rather than the people who prepare your year-end statements. In Canada that often means chartered professional accountants, sometimes working with chartered business valuators. Your own accountant knows the business well, but a buyer will give more weight to a firm with no history with you.
Ask any firm you are considering how many sell-side reports it has done for companies your size, who will actually do the work, and whether buyers in your industry have relied on its reports before.
How much does a quality of earnings report cost, and how long does it take?
We know of no published survey of Canadian fees. As a reference point, one US firm, Eton Venture Services, lists US$25,000 to US$35,000 for businesses under US$10 million in revenue and from about US$60,000 for larger ones, with most engagements taking four to eight weeks. Canadian quotes vary with the size of the company, the number of entities, the state of the records and how fast you need it.
Time is usually the bigger cost. Most delays come from the owner’s side: missing contracts, payroll records that don’t tie out, or add-backs with no paper behind them. Get quotes from two or three firms and confirm the scope in writing before you compare prices.
How to prepare for a quality of earnings review
The work that makes a QoE go smoothly is the same work that raises what a buyer will pay, and most of it takes time. It belongs in the 1 to 2 years before a sale.
- Move to monthly financial statements that close on time and tie to the bank.
- Build an add-back schedule with a reason and a record for every line, for three years plus the current year.
- Stop running personal costs through the company, and put any rent you charge the company on a written lease at a market rate.
- Split revenue by customer, product and month, so concentration and trends are visible before a buyer finds them.
- Gather the contracts: customers, suppliers, leases, loans and key employees.
- Ask your accountant whether a review engagement makes sense for the years a buyer will study.
- Order a sell-side QoE before you go to market, not after an offer arrives.
Our method shows how we sequence this work with owners, and the Pre-Flight Kit has the checklists we use to start.
Confirm the accounting and tax points with your accountant. If you would like to know how your numbers would read to a buyer’s accountants, a short, private conversation is a good place to start.
Common questions
What does a quality of earnings report look like?
Most open with a short summary of normalized EBITDA and the key findings, followed by schedules for each adjustment, revenue, margins, working capital and debt. Reports for larger deals can run to many pages of tables.
Is a quality of earnings report the same as a business valuation?
No. A valuation estimates what the business is worth. A QoE tests the earnings a buyer’s price is built on, and leaves the multiple to the negotiation.
What is the quality of earnings ratio?
It is operating cash flow divided by net income, a quick check investors use on whether profit turns into cash. It is a different thing from the quality of earnings report used in a sale.
Do I need a sell-side quality of earnings report to sell my business?
It is not required. It is most useful when your statements are compiled rather than reviewed or audited, when you have significant add-backs, or when you expect private equity or other experienced buyers.